Sweeney Todd (2007)

Spoiler-free impressions:
It's hard to judge this one as a film, having recently seen John's Doyle's award-winning production on Broadway, featuring a stripped-down cast and minimalist set design. Tim Burton's film, by contrast, is positively (perhaps needlessly?) maximalist: the grime is grimiest, the blood is bloodiest, the squalor is, um, squalidest. It's pretty much exactly what you'd expert Tim Burton to do with Sweeney Todd: cast Johnny Depp in the lead (as usual), alongside his muse/girlfriend Helena Bonham-Carter (as usual), Alan Rickman as the dour British guy (his usual role), Timothy Spall as the smarmy British sycophant (having, in 2007 alone, tackled that role in Harry Potter 5 and again as Fagin in a BBC adaptation of Oliver Twist)... and then slap the usual coat of Tim Burton patina (squiggly black curlicue hair, desaturated tones) over the source material, adding little and illuminating less.
What strengths exist in the film-- and there are many-- are doubly strong, however, on Broadway: the counterpoint and consummate Britishness of the songs, the suspense of the murders, and ultimately the themes (primarily the central counterpoint of protagonist and villain, the barber versus the judge, the lowly versus the powerful). Depp does his best Bowie impression on the musical numbers and the cast sings surprisingly well (perhaps with the aid of digital correction?), but there's no remotely essential, let alone breakthrough, performance...
A decent film with some flashes of inspiration in the imagery, but overall a perfunctory and forgettable adaptation.





Each and every paragraph in The Dirt, the story of Mötley Crüe, puts the wildest night of your life to shame. The Crüe's excess would make freakin Caligula look like a prude, and anyone hoping to top their insane heights of drugs, sex, and rock n roll would find themselves dead, simply dead, cause the Crüe came within an inch plenty of times. 



